Now that New York Yankees' shortstop has announced he will retire after the 2014 the Derek Jeter ass kissing festival has kicked into overdrive. Jeter has already achieved sainthood but now things are getting ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, I am not a Derek Jeter hater. I do think he is a future Hall Of Famer but I do think he is overrated. In many cases Jeter's myth has actually surpassed what he has done on the field. As a ballplayer, I think he is the carbon copy of Craig Biggio or Michael Young.
Let me explain my reasoning before you write me off as a Jeter hater. First of all Jeter as a ballplayer was born with a silver spoon in his mouth. He came into the big leagues with the free spending New York Yankees. A team which had a virtual financial stranglehold on the game of baseball during the bulk of Jeter's career. Jeter was in a lineup packed with All Stars for virtually every season of his career. He never had to be "THE MAN" and never faced an ounce of adversity in his entire career. He batted lead-off or second just about every season in front of a lineup of the highest paid sluggers in the game (which of course meant that Jeter saw a large quantity of fastballs right over the plate.)
On the field Jeter's numbers were above average but not staggering. Jeter never won an MVP or a batting title. For his career, he led the AL in hits twice, runs once, at bats once and plate appearances four times and that's it. To that most will say "well Jeter was about championships not stats." Sure Jeter won 5 championships on Yankee teams that had the highest payrolls in baseball by far. Let's look at the flipside, Jeter was front and center on numerous Yankee teams that underachieved with the highest payroll in baseball. He was shortstop on a team that lost to the bargain basement Florida Marlins in 2003.
On the field Jeter was an excellent singles hitter. He was an average defensive shortstop at best with an average arm (why do you think he had to jump to make throws to first!) He also struck out a LOT (did you know he is the all time Yankees strikeout leader?) Jeter was an above average player on a team jam packed with superstars every year. You can argue that for the majority of his career Jeter was not even the best player on his own team.
Then there was Jeter's role as Yankee team captain. What exactly did being Yankee captain mean? It meant that he was the leader of a team that was soaked in steroids and cheating. But somehow Jeter knew nothing about it. While the majority of the Yankee superstars were busing sticking needles in each other's asses, Jeter was off by himself having his milk and cookies and had no idea what was going on. That's like a member of the Grateful Dead saying he had no idea the rest of the band were doing drugs! In my mind Jeter does not get a pass from steroid doubts just because he's friendly to the media. Jeter looked done in 2011, then he comes back a year later and leads the AL in hits and very few eyebrows get raised.
But you just can't say anything bad about St. Jeter. Even when Jeter was voted most overrated player in baseball by his peers year after year, the response was that they were all just jealous of the great Jeter. Let's face it Jeter has never done anything wrong. He doesn't even have bathrooms at his house because he never goes to the bathrooms. Jeter can now join St. Mo Rivera in heaven as they get ready to walk on water at an ocean near you.
No comments:
Post a Comment